Vanity Fair New Establishment Summit - Day 1

Elon Musk and Sam Altman in 2015. (Michael Kovac/Getty Images)

MUSK BEEF

OpenAI: Elon literally wanted us to be for-profit!

OpenAI brings receipts showing Musk wanted them to be for-profit before he sued them for doing just that.

12/13/24 4:30PM

“You can’t sue your way to AGI.”

That is the pointed message from OpenAI to cofounder Elon Musk that appears in a lengthy blog post today on the company’s website, the second such post to publicly push back on Musk’s legal attacks on the company.

In a post titled “Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit” the company makes the case that Musk, who has filed multiple lawsuits to stop OpenAI from altering its core structure to a for-profit business, actually wanted that structure in the first place and even filed the paperwork to do that.

Currently, the company is structured as primary nonprofit entity, with a smaller for-profit arm.

OpenAI lays out a timeline to the key events in the feud since OpenAI’s founding in 2015. The post showed the receipts in the form of text-message threads detailing Musk meetings as well as redacted emails to and from Musk that all appear to show that Musk was indeed in favor of the for-profit approach to raise the huge amounts of capital needed to build the computing infrastructure and produce the first tangible results of their efforts.

According to a reading of OpenAI’s version of events, Musk seemed to be supportive and on-board until September 2017, when the founders were discussing the equity allocation for the for-profit arm. According to the post, Musk wanted 50% to 60% ownership of the company and to be CEO.

“On one call, Elon told us he didn’t care about equity personally but just needed to accumulate $80B for a city on Mars.”

After detailing his preferred terms for the new for-profit entity, Musk told founders Ilya Sutskever and Greg Brockman in an email:

“I’ve been really impressed with the quality of discussion with you guys on the equity and board stuff. I have a really good feeling about this. “

Two days later, Musk’s agents registered a public-benefit corporation named “Open Artificial Intelligence Technologies, Inc.” in Delaware.

Sutskever responded with the OpenAI team’s concerns in an email to Musk titled “Honest Thoughts,” which did not land well with Musk. Sutskever wrote:

“The goal of OpenAI is to make the future good and to avoid an AGI dictatorship. You are concerned that Demis [presumably Nobel Prize recipient and Google DeepMind CEO Demis Hassabis] could create an AGI dictatorship. So do we. So it is a bad idea to create a structure where you could become a dictator if you chose to, especially given that we can create some other structure that avoids this possibility.”

That appeared to trigger the famously mercurial Musk, as evidenced by his curt reply:

“Guys, I’ve had enough. This is the final straw.
Either go do something on your own or continue with OpenAI as a nonprofit. I will no longer fund OpenAI until you have made a firm commitment to stay or I’m just being a fool who is essentially providing free funding for you to create a startup.
Discussions are over.”

The post goes on to detail more examples of Musk supporting the for-profit model and urging the company to raise vast sums of capital as quickly as possible. In January 2018, Musk suggested rolling OpenAI into publicly traded Tesla, offering the company a $1 billion budget, which Altman and the others were opposed to.

While things appeared chilly heading into 2018, Musk still communicated with Sam Altman and the others, casting doubt on their chosen path forward. Musk wrote to the OpenAI team:

“My probability assessment of OpenAI being relevant to DeepMind/Google without a dramatic change in execution and resources is 0%. Not 1%. I wish it were otherwise.
Even raising several hundred million won’t be enough. This needs billions per year immediately or forget it.”

After Musk saw OpenAI’s fundraising achieve a valuation of $20 billion, Musk was angry. In a text to Altman, Musk said that he provided the bulk of the seed funding for OpenAI and was left without any equity (which OpenAI says he declined).

“This is a bait and switch,” Musk wrote.

A few months later, Musk founded his OpenAI competitor, xAI, and cosigned a letter calling for an industry-wide pause on AI development.

Rani Molla

Tunnel Vision

14h

Tesla gets permit to test autonomous cars in Nevada as autonomous driving heats up there

Amazon’s self-driving Zoox launched service this week, and Google’s Waymo is testing there.

Las Vegas Exteriors And Landmarks - 2024

Jon Keegan

9/11/25

OpenAI and Microsoft reach agreement that moves OpenAI closer to for-profit status

In a joint statement, OpenAI and Microsoft announced a “non-binding memorandum of understanding” for their renegotiated $13 billion partnership, which was a source of recent tension between the two companies.

Settling the agreement is a requirement to clear the way for OpenAI to convert to a for-profit public benefit corporation, which it must do before a year-end deadline to secure a $20 billion investment from SoftBank.

OpenAI also announced that the controlling nonprofit arm would hold an equity stake in the PBC valued at $100 billion, which would make it “one of the most well-resourced philanthropic organizations in the world.”

The statement read:

“This recapitalization would also enable us to raise the capital required to accomplish our mission — and ensure that as OpenAI’s PBC grows, so will the nonprofit’s resources, allowing us to bring it to historic levels of community impact.”

A joint statement from OpenAI and Microsoft

The statement read:

“This recapitalization would also enable us to raise the capital required to accomplish our mission — and ensure that as OpenAI’s PBC grows, so will the nonprofit’s resources, allowing us to bring it to historic levels of community impact.”

Rani Molla

9/11/25

BofA doesn’t expect Tesla’s ride-share service to have an impact on Uber or Lyft this year

Analysts at Bank of America Global Research compared Tesla’s new Bay Area ride-sharing service with its rivals and found that, for now, it’s not much competition for Uber and Lyft. “Tesla scale in SF is still small, and we don’t expect impact on Uber/Lyft financial performance in ’25,” they wrote.

Tesla is operating an unknown number of cars with drivers using supervised full self-driving in the Bay Area, and roughly 30 autonomous robotaxis in Austin. The company has allowed the public to download its Robotaxi app and join a waitlist, but it hasn’t said how many people have been let in off that waitlist.

While the analysts found that Tesla ride-shares are cheaper than traditional ride-share services like Uber and Lyft, the wait times are a lot longer (nine-minute wait times on average, when cars were available at all) and the process has more friction. They also said the “nature of [a] Tesla FSD ‘driver’ is slightly more aggressive than a Waymo,” the Google-owned company that’s currently operating 800 vehicles in the Bay Area.

Apple AI was MIA at iPhone event

A year and a half into a bungled rollout of AI into Apple’s products, Apple Intelligence was barely mentioned at the “Awe Dropping” event.

Jon Keegan9/10/25

Jon Keegan

9/10/25

Oracle’s massive sales backlog is thanks to a $300 billion deal with OpenAI, WSJ reports

OpenAI has signed a massive deal to purchase $300 billion worth of cloud computing capacity from Oracle, according to a report from The Wall Street Journal.

The report notes that the five-year deal would be one of the largest cloud computing contracts ever signed, requiring 4.5 gigawatts of capacity.

The news is prompting shares to pare some of their massive gains, presumably because of concerns about counterparty and concentration risk.

Yesterday, Oracle shares skyrocketed as much as 30% in after-hours trading after the company forecast that it expects its cloud infrastructure business to see revenues climb to $144 billion by 2030.

Oracle shares were up as much as 43% on Wednesday.

It’s the second example in under a week of how much OpenAI’s cash burn and fundraising efforts are playing a starring role in the AI boom: the Financial Times reported that OpenAI is also the major new Broadcom customer that has placed $10 billion in orders.

Exclusive | Oracle, OpenAI Sign Massive $300 Billion Cloud Computing Deal