Culture
Critics vs. audiences: Fan favorites don't often win at the Academy Awards

Critics vs. audiences: Fan favorites don't often win at the Academy Awards

Winning everything

‍_Everything Everywhere All At Once_ (EEAAO) was a big winner at last night’s 95th Academy Awards, taking home a total of 7 Oscars including best picture, best director, best actress, best original screenplay, and more.

The movie, the second best picture winner from indie studio A24, was a standout favorite in some categories. Despite a relatively limited budget, EEAAO managed a solid showing in cinemas — grossing over $100 million worldwide — but also won gushing critical response too.

Agree to disagreeObviously being popular with both reviewers and audiences is a winning formula, but the Academy often gives the gong to movies that win more relative favor with critics, rather than big box office blockbusters.

That trend can be seen in data from Rotten Tomatoes, a website that aggregates movie reviews from everyday users and professional critics. Since 1990, just 8 best picture winners have been favored more by fans than critics, compared to 23 in the opposite direction, including EEAAO. Forrest Gump is the most extreme split between audiences and critics, with a 95% audience approval and only a 71% critic approval rating. 2018’s The Shape of Water was the opposite, with a 92% fresh rating amongst critics, but just 72% from viewers.

More Culture

See all Culture
Family in front of TV

Hollywood may have its best year at the box office since 2019, but streaming audiences are still obsessed with old content

Viewers are opting for catalog content over new shows and movies across (pretty much) every major streamer.

Tom Jones6/29/26
culture
Tom Jones

The BBC has become the world’s top news website... by collapsing a little less than its competition

Press Gazette just published its annual look at the biggest news sites in the world across all languages; for the most part, it doesn’t make for particularly pretty reading.

The journalism industry publication’s latest update, which is based on estimates provided by Similarweb for May, found that 37 of the world’s 50 most visited news sites saw their reach shrink. Press Gazette highlighted that American outlets have been hit particularly hard by declining Google traffic compared to European counterparts, owing to the platform’s AI features rolling out earlier in the US.

Even the BBC, having climbed the rankings from last year to top the 2026 chart — reportedly in part thanks to Similarweb’s decision to combine the “.co.uk” and “.com” versions of the URL, given that the sites redirect to each other depending on the user’s location — showed a 1.9% decline from last year.

Latest Stories

Sherwood Media, LLC and Chartr Limited produce fresh and unique perspectives on topical financial news and are fully owned subsidiaries of Robinhood Markets, Inc., and any views expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of any other Robinhood affiliate, including Robinhood Markets, Inc., Robinhood Financial LLC, Robinhood Securities, LLC, Robinhood Crypto, LLC, Robinhood Money, LLC, Robinhood U.K. Ltd, Robinhood Derivatives, LLC, Robinhood Gold, LLC, Robinhood Asset Management, LLC, Robinhood Credit, Inc., Robinhood Ventures DE, LLC and, where applicable, its managed investment vehicles.